Search

Search

Eye Pencil

A mineral-based eye pencil with a soft formula that will not tug at delicate skin. Made with conditioning oils and waxes. Can be used anywhere on the face. 

Color: Black / Brown
Basic Black
Basic Brown
Black / Brown
Black / Grey
Midnight Blue
Taupe

Overall rating: 4.3976436 / 5 from 679 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

This mineral-based eye pencil offers a smooth and easy application with a soft formula that is gentle on delicate skin. Customers appreciate its precise line, natural look, and excellent staying power. The quality and conditioning properties are also highly praised.

Summary topics

  • Texture: 3%
  • Color: 32%
  • Staying Power: 4%
  • Application: 8%
  • Line Precision: 10%

Review topics: [ingredients, irritation, quality, service, color, feels, spots, problem, texture, consistency, packaging, price, formula, skin, look, lines, eyes, shade, coverage, shipping, touch, everyday, beauty, use, appearance, works, foundation, pencil, eyeliner, application].

Review highlights

  • "I am fair, and this colour looks so soft and natural, yet neatly defines my eyes!"Linde
  • "love the color - ease of application; smooth texture"Virginia Q.
  • "Creamy texture and easy to get a precise or smudgy line, depending on my preference"Susan W.

Reviews

Lovely

"Lovely brown eyeliner it stays in place and does not move it is great thank you. I would love to see shimmer colors soon!"

Lunations (5/5)

Perfect pencil!

"I love the midnight blue. It makes the white in my eyes look brighter! It goes on well and I keep it the sharp I love the midnight blue. It makes the white in my eyes look brighter!"

Karen T. (5/5)

No, I would not recommend

"No, I would not recommend this pencil. The color is not intense enough for me, especially for the cost."

Karen G. (3/5)

Great eye pencil

"This pencil glides on easily and stays all day. Love the black/brown."

Laura K. (5/5)

Soft and creamy but has staying power

"A very nice eye pencil that is soft enough to glide on application and not drag, yet has nice staying power! I like a natural look and prefer a non waterproof eyeliner due to sensitive eyes. I also don’t care about something having a 20 hour wear time! It lasted all day. Love the clean ingredients also."

Wynnedee T. (5/5)

Great Liner

"This eyeliner goes on smooth and lasts all day."

Tabitha B. (5/5)

Goes on so smooth! Color

"Goes on so smooth! Color is perfect for fair skin!"

Jenna V. (5/5)

glides on easily

"glides on easily and does not irritate eyes"

Tamta B. (5/5)

Creamy texture and easy to apply

"Creamy texture. Easy to apply. Doesn't pull skin as you are applying it. Love the black/brown color."

carol t. (5/5)

Eye pencil

"Great product been using for years"

Robin W. (5/5)

Q&A

I am 69 years young, i have green eyes medium brown hair and medium complexion which color eyeliner be best for me
We suggest Black/Grey Eye Pencil!
How much quantity comes in a pencil? Thanks!
The Eye Pencil is .04 oz!
Are your eyeliners and lipliners waterproof? I know they last very well but need to know if fully water proof?
Great question! They are water resistant, not waterproof.
Do you have to sharpen this pencil
Yes, it needs to be sharpened with our Pencil Sharpener!
What does the code mean on the side of my eye pencil?
Hi there! We're happy to assist with your recent purchase. Please contact us at 877-869-9420 or BeautyAdvisors@janeiredale.com.